Keymar Real Estate

Keymar Real Estate

Welcome to Keymar, Maryland – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Carroll County. This quaint town offers a perfect blend of rural charm and modern convenience, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

Keymar boasts a rich history, with roots dating back to the 19th century. As you stroll through the town, you'll be captivated by its picturesque landscapes, friendly community, and a strong sense of belonging. The town is surrounded by lush farmland and rolling hills, providing residents with stunning views and ample opportunities for outdoor activities. Whether you enjoy hiking, biking, or simply taking a leisurely walk, the natural beauty of Keymar will inspire you.

One of the standout features of Keymar is its proximity to larger cities like Westminster and Frederick, which are just a short drive away. This means you can enjoy the tranquility of small-town living while still having easy access to shopping, dining, and entertainment options. Local farmers' markets, cozy cafes, and family-owned businesses add to the town's charm and foster a strong community spirit.

Families will appreciate the excellent schools in the area, along with a plethora of parks and recreational facilities that cater to all ages. With a tight-knit community and a welcoming atmosphere, Keymar is a place where neighbors become friends and lifelong memories are made.

If you're looking for a serene and inviting place to call home, Keymar, Maryland, may just be the perfect destination for you. Come explore the warmth and beauty of this delightful town – your new adventure awaits!

Newest Listings in Keymar

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Headline: Charming 1914 Colonial with Exceptional Outbuildings on 1 Acre Discover the perfect blend of historic charm and versatile space. Situated on nearly an acre of land, this 1,540 sq. ft. colonial is ready for its next chapter. You’ll love the nice size kitchen, complete with a functional island and stainless steel appliances, providing a great space to cook and entertain. While this home offers 4 bedrooms and 2 baths and a detached 2-car garage, the true standout features are the grounds: property highlights include a historic school building and several additional outdoor structures, offering incredible potential for a home business, artist studio, or hobby farm. Major infrastructure updates are already complete, including a new septic system and roof installed within the last two years. The home is a sturdy foundation for your renovation goals. Whether you’re looking to embrace a classic architectural style or need room to grow your projects, this property provides the space and history to do both.

12109 Woodsboro Pike, Keymar

Listing courtesy of Charis Realty Group. Contact: 3018315099

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Pack your bags - all the work has been done for you! Enjoy the tranquility of rural living with the convenience of one level in this completely remodeled and updated home on 3.63 acres. Walk onto the covered, composite deck, front porch to enter through the front door into the great room (living room, eat-in kitchen, and dining area) featuring a wood burning, granite surround fireplace with a gas line installed for easy conversion. This split floor plan has the primary suite located on one end of the house with the other bedroom, bonus room, and full bath on the other end. Look onto the backyard from the sunroom with its own heating/cooling system. Stay out of the weather entering the mudroom, from your covered back porch, with the accommodating drop zone for outerwear and backpacks. Downstairs you'll find a bedroom with direct, full bath access, a family room, and a large laundry room. A full walkup attic provides sought after storage. Outside you'll find a barn with electricity, a two vehicle carport, and shed. Enjoy the open design gazebo with a dual sink and running water for the benefit of outdoor entertaining. Driveway to be paved September 10, 2026. Look for the orange markings at the driveway and near the house showing the outline of here the paving will be done. Updates include: architectural shingles, vinyl siding, LVP flooring throughout, kitchen (SS appliances, granite counter tops, new cabinets and farm sink), bathrooms, newly created primary suite, paint throughout, light fixtures, fireplace, HVAC, water heater. One year warranty from date of installation: HVAC, plumbing, kitchen appliances, vinyl siding, and roof shingles.

11860 Nicholson Rd, Keymar

Listing courtesy of Kelley Real Estate Professionals. Contact:

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

One of a kind property — a true must-see! This beautifully maintained rancher offers 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths, highlighted by a huge sunroom addition overlooking the backyard and fresh water pond. The fully finished lower level adds even more living space, featuring a full bathroom, living room, and an expansive rec room with a wet bar, gas fireplace, and walk-out access at grade to a covered patio. Two additional patios flank each side of the home, offering multiple outdoor entertaining spaces. A detached 3-bay garage provides room for up to 5 vehicles, and an automatic greenhouse sits just behind it — perfect for the hobby gardener. But the true showstopper is the massive 50x60 outbuilding included with the sale. One side features an oversized garage door built to accommodate nearly any size RV — a 40-foot RV fits with room to spare. The other side, accessed through a standard garage bay, includes a dedicated vinyl-sided vehicle wash room for year-round car care, plus an additional storage room behind it. Upstairs, a bonus 2-bedroom apartment (not fully completed) offers exciting potential as an income-producing rental or an in-law suite. This exceptional property must be seen in person to truly appreciate everything it offers — schedule your private showing today!

5933 Keysville Rd, Keymar

Listing courtesy of EXP Realty, LLC. Contact: 8888607369

Well and septic availability needs to be verified by the buyer. Owner says perc test was done long ago but cannot find the paperwork.

Baumgardner Rd S, Keymar

Listing courtesy of Long & Foster Real Estate, Inc.. Contact: 4107959600

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Investor opportunity. Property is being sold strictly as‑is and is valued primarily for the land and future use. Existing improvements contribute minimal value and require substantial rehabilitation. Ideal for buyers seeking a project with redevelopment or major renovation potential. Cash or renovation financing recommended. Buyer to perform all due diligence regarding zoning, utilities, and intended use. Virtually staged/AI-enhanced photos illustrate potential improvements; see original photos for current condition.

2143 Keysville Frederick Co Rd, Keymar

Listing courtesy of Maryland Realty Connection. Contact: 3017129374

Start Your Search

Kathleen McMahan

For Kathleen McMahan, real estate has always been about more than buying and selling homes. It’s about people, relationships, and helping clients feel confident during some of the biggest transitions of their lives. With more than a decade of experience in Maryland and Washington, D.C. real estate, Kathleen has built her business around a simple philosophy: stay positive, work hard, communicate honestly, and treat every client’s move as if it were her own. Positivity has long been Kathleen’s “north star,” both personally and professionally. When her oldest son spent time in the NICU, she focused on learning everything she could from his nurses so she would feel prepared when it was finally time to bring him home. That experience reinforced something she carries into her work today: even during stressful and uncertain moments, knowledge, preparation, and the right perspective can make all the difference. That mindset has helped Kathleen build a successful real estate career based largely on relationships, referrals, and clients who return to her as their lives and real estate needs evolve. Now, as the agent behind McMahan Homes at Real Broker, she brings the experience of more than a decade in the industry together with the personal attention and flexibility of an independent real estate business. Originally from New Jersey, Kathleen came to Maryland to attend Salisbury University. Her studies in sociology and marketing helped spark a lasting curiosity about people—what motivates them, what matters to them, and what makes a place truly feel like home. Today, that curiosity is one of her greatest strengths as an agent. Kathleen takes the time to understand not just what her clients are looking for on paper, but what they want their lives to look like. Whether she’s preparing a home for the market, negotiating on behalf of a seller, helping a buyer find the right community, or simply answering the questions that come up along the way, her goal is to make the process feel informed, personal, and manageable. Kathleen lives in Maryland with her husband and two sons. When she isn’t working, you’ll most likely find her spending time with her family, dreaming about her next trip to the Florida Keys, or planning her next home project.

Learn More