Bryn Athyn Homes for Sale

Bryn Athyn Homes for Sale

Welcome to Bryn Athyn, Pennsylvania, a charming community nestled in Montgomery County that seamlessly blends historical richness with modern living. Renowned for its picturesque landscapes and a close-knit atmosphere, Bryn Athyn is not just a place to live; it's a place to thrive.

One of the standout features of Bryn Athyn is its exceptional school district, which is dedicated to providing top-notch education to its students. The district prioritizes academic excellence, fostering a nurturing environment where children can explore their interests and develop their skills. With a range of extracurricular activities and a commitment to individualized learning, families can rest assured that their children are receiving a well-rounded education. The small class sizes allow for personalized attention, ensuring that every student feels valued and supported.

For those looking to make Bryn Athyn their home, the real estate market offers a variety of charming homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From quaint cottages with historical significance to modern family homes equipped with contemporary amenities, there is something for everyone in this delightful community. Each property reflects the unique character of Bryn Athyn, providing a warm and inviting atmosphere for families and individuals alike.

Living in Bryn Athyn means enjoying a peaceful suburban lifestyle while being just a short drive from the vibrant city life of Philadelphia. With its top-rated schools, beautiful homes, and a strong sense of community, Bryn Athyn is the perfect place to call home. Explore the available homes for sale today and discover the charm of Bryn Athyn!

Newest Bryn Athyn Homes for Sale

6 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Set in the heart of Bryn Athyn, this spacious and character-filled 6+ bedroom home offers a rare combination of size, flexibility, and charm. With 2 full baths, 2 half baths, including a separate apartment, the property provides endless possibilities for multigenerational living, guest space, a private office, or potential rental income. From the moment you enter, the home showcases timeless details and inviting living spaces. Hardwood floors, distinctive windows, classic built-ins, and unique architectural touches create warmth and personality throughout. The living room features a beautiful wood-burning fireplace, while across the hall is a dining/family room offers the comfort of a gas fireplace for cozy evenings and entertaining alike. Designed for both everyday living and flexibility, the home includes a convenient second-floor laundry room that could easily be converted back into an additional bedroom if needed. A charming sleeping porch offers a quiet retreat, and multiple indoor and outdoor gathering spaces make the home feel both comfortable and expansive. Step outside to enjoy the beautiful deck, spacious screened-in porch, raised garden beds ready for vegetables and seasonal plantings, and a dedicated fire pit area perfect for relaxing evenings outdoors. A nearby shed provides convenient storage for gardening tools and equipment. Combined with the property's remarkably low taxes, helping to keep ownership costs manageable year after year. Combined with the income potential of the apartment and the home's generous size and flexibility, this is a truly unique opportunity to own a one-of-a-kind property that can adapt to your lifestyle while helping support your budget. The home's location in one of the area’s most sought-after communities, this is a truly special opportunity to own a one-of-a-kind home with room to grow and make your own. Price recently reduced!!! Call for your private showing!

2701 Alden Rd, Bryn Athyn

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Hearthside Realtors. Contact:

5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths

Nestled on a private, beautifully landscaped lot of nearly half an acre, this spacious 5+ bedroom home offers the perfect blend of charm, functionality, and exceptional value in highly sought-after Bryn Athyn Borough—featuring remarkably low combined taxes of under $3,800/year. A circular driveway provides ample parking and leads to an oversized 2+ car garage with soaring ceilings—ideal for large vehicles, a workshop, or even a car lift. An attached bonus space offers incredible flexibility and potential—perfect for a studio, gym, home office, hobby area, or creative workspace tailored to your needs. The inviting exterior showcases outstanding gardens, a welcoming front porch with serene views, and a brick patio perfect for outdoor dining and entertaining. Inside, the home features both front and rear foyer entrances for added convenience. The main level boasts beautiful southern yellow pine floors, a spacious living room with a fireplace, a large formal dining room with access to the rear patio, and a bright family room off the kitchen with a vaulted ceiling and bay window. A well-appointed kitchen area includes generous counter space and a nearby powder room. A private first-floor office adds versatility for today’s lifestyle. The second floor offers three bedrooms, including a primary suite with a walk-in closet and a spa-like en suite bath featuring a large tiled shower with glass enclosure and a soaking tub. Two additional bedrooms and a full hall bath complete this level. The third floor provides two more generously sized bedrooms and a full tiled bathroom, along with abundant storage in the eaves. Ideally located just minutes from the quaint shops and restaurants of Huntingdon Valley, this exceptional property offers both privacy and convenience. Recently reduced! Schedule this one today!

755 Fetters Mill Rd, Huntingdon Valley

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Hearthside Realtors. Contact:

5 Beds ⋅ 7 Baths

Some properties are defined by their finishes. Others by their size or setting. 3080 Paper Mill Road brings all three together in one remarkable estate. Privately positioned on 5 acres adjoining more than 800 acres of preserved Pennypack Trust land, this approximately 16,600-square-foot custom French Normandy residence offers a level of scale and construction that would be extraordinarily difficult to duplicate anywhere near today’s asking price. Built as the personal residence of a luxury builder, the home showcases substantial construction and thoughtful architectural detailing throughout. Limestone flooring, coffered ceilings, custom millwork and five fireplaces establish the character of the residence, beginning with an impressive foyer and continuing through beautifully proportioned formal and informal living spaces. At the heart of the home is a custom kitchen appointed with Calacatta marble, extensive cabinetry, oversized island, breakfast area and adjoining fireside hearth room. Nearby, the soaring two-story great room is centered around a dramatic floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace with sweeping views across the property. French doors from the formal living room open to an outdoor terrace, creating an effortless connection between indoor and outdoor entertaining. The primary suite provides its own private sanctuary with a sitting room, fireplace, multiple walk-in closets, spa-inspired bath and private balcony. Additional en-suite bedrooms offer beautifully appointed accommodations for family and guests. The finished lower level feels almost like a destination of its own, offering a full bar, catering area, second kitchen, expansive entertainment and game spaces, bedroom, full bath and glass-walled gym overlooking the grounds. Beyond the main residence, a separate carriage house with approximately 22-foot ceilings provides outstanding flexibility for an office, studio or guest space. Seven total garage spaces accommodate everything from everyday vehicles to an impressive automobile collection. This is an estate where replacement value deserves serious consideration. From the acreage and approximately 16,600 square feet of finished space to the architectural detailing, carriage house, garages and extraordinary preserved setting, attempting to recreate a property of this magnitude today would represent an entirely different proposition. A rare opportunity to acquire substantial luxury, privacy and craftsmanship in one exceptional property. .

3080 Paper Mill Rd, Bryn Athyn

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Real Estate-Montgomeryville. Contact:

Start Your Search

Kathleen McMahan

For Kathleen McMahan, real estate has always been about more than buying and selling homes. It’s about people, relationships, and helping clients feel confident during some of the biggest transitions of their lives. With more than a decade of experience in Maryland and Washington, D.C. real estate, Kathleen has built her business around a simple philosophy: stay positive, work hard, communicate honestly, and treat every client’s move as if it were her own. Positivity has long been Kathleen’s “north star,” both personally and professionally. When her oldest son spent time in the NICU, she focused on learning everything she could from his nurses so she would feel prepared when it was finally time to bring him home. That experience reinforced something she carries into her work today: even during stressful and uncertain moments, knowledge, preparation, and the right perspective can make all the difference. That mindset has helped Kathleen build a successful real estate career based largely on relationships, referrals, and clients who return to her as their lives and real estate needs evolve. Now, as the agent behind McMahan Homes at Real Broker, she brings the experience of more than a decade in the industry together with the personal attention and flexibility of an independent real estate business. Originally from New Jersey, Kathleen came to Maryland to attend Salisbury University. Her studies in sociology and marketing helped spark a lasting curiosity about people—what motivates them, what matters to them, and what makes a place truly feel like home. Today, that curiosity is one of her greatest strengths as an agent. Kathleen takes the time to understand not just what her clients are looking for on paper, but what they want their lives to look like. Whether she’s preparing a home for the market, negotiating on behalf of a seller, helping a buyer find the right community, or simply answering the questions that come up along the way, her goal is to make the process feel informed, personal, and manageable. Kathleen lives in Maryland with her husband and two sons. When she isn’t working, you’ll most likely find her spending time with her family, dreaming about her next trip to the Florida Keys, or planning her next home project.

Learn More